Blog

The slow death of pay-per-user

AI agents can now complete certain tasks without user interaction, so charging for corporate software per user no longer makes sense for vendors. Providers like Salesforce, Microsoft, and SAP have therefore begun to charge by the task in addition to their per-user subscription fees.

In this article 7 sections

Executive summary

  • Corporate software has been sold as a subscription per user for decades. Its largest vendors are now moving beyond that model: SAP is retiring all but one of its per-user AI packages, Microsoft’s chief executive calls pricing per user “just entitlement to some consumption”, and his counterpart at Salesforce says his company is “still trapped in some ways” in the old model.
  • Per-user pricing rested on three conditions: the software’s value reached the customer through its users, the marginal cost of an additional user was close to zero, and lock-in meant customers rarely left. AI agents remove the first two. They complete tasks without a user, and each task costs the vendor computing power.
  • Vendors now charge by the task on top of the licence fees, usually in credits bought in advance that expire if unused. Microsoft calls this “seats plus consumption” and tells investors it will raise revenue per user.
  • What a task costs depends on who else can complete it, and vendors have begun to charge when outside agents reach the customer’s data. Salesforce has announced such a charge without yet naming the rate.

On 26 August 2026, Salesforce told investors that the AI agent on its own help site had handled more than 5 million customer conversations and resolved 64% of them without an employee (opens in a new tab). A conversation that no employee handles needs no user licence. Salesforce sells this kind of agent, software that completes a defined task with some independence, at $2 for each conversation it resolves (opens in a new tab).

On the same call, Gabriela Borges of Goldman Sachs asked (opens in a new tab) whether Salesforce would earn as much from customers who use its platform through agents, without its interface. “We’re still trapped in some ways in old per-user pricing models,” replied Marc Benioff, the chief executive. “But the opportunity to build much more aggressive pricing to really represent the value that we’re offering our customers, I think, is enormous.”

User licences, which the industry calls seats, will stay on invoices for years: Salesforce has raised its list prices per user (opens in a new tab) and says its seats are growing. However, the licence is slowly ceasing to be the measure of the bill. Satya Nadella, Microsoft’s chief executive, told analysts in April 2026 (opens in a new tab) that “seat-based pricing is just entitlement to some consumption”, which makes the licence a package of usage rights.

What will companies pay for once the user no longer measures what software does? Our answer is that vendors will charge for each task on top of the licence, and that the price of a task will depend on whether other providers’ agents can reach the customer’s data. Both are settled in the contract, which makes the next renewal the moment to act.

What a user licence measured

Per-user pricing worked for decades because it rested on three conditions, and Salesforce’s annual report for fiscal 2026 (opens in a new tab) has a figure for each.

The software’s value reached the customer through its users. A user was an employee handling cases in the system, so counting users measured what the software did. Salesforce’s sales and service products, whose editions are priced per user, brought in 48% of its subscription and support revenue.

The marginal cost of an additional user was close to zero. One system serves all customers, so delivering its subscriptions cost Salesforce 17% of the revenue they brought in, and the price could be the same for every user.

Customers rarely left, because moving their data and integrations to another system is costly, an effect known as lock-in. Salesforce’s attrition, the share of contract value it loses in a year, was about 8%. That made a high customer acquisition cost worth paying, and Salesforce spent 35% of its revenue on sales and marketing.

While all three conditions held, counting users was a fair measure for the customer and a safe one for the vendor. AI agents remove the first two, and the third, lock-in, decides what customers will pay instead.

Agents remove users and raise marginal cost

The better a vendor’s agents become, the fewer licences its customer needs for the same work. Under per-user pricing, a vendor that improves its product therefore reduces its own revenue.

SAP has already acted on this. It is retiring all but one of its per-user AI packages (opens in a new tab) in January 2027, while the subscription for its core systems stays as it is. Its training material (opens in a new tab) says the value of AI “is no longer determined by how many users have access, but by how much work AI actually performs”.

So far, however, there is little sign of falling licence numbers in vendors’ results. The one case we found is Microsoft, whose finance chief said in April 2026 that bookings growth for the Dynamics 365 business software “was impacted by weaker renewals as customers balance spend between the traditional per seat and the emerging seats plus consumption model”.

At the same time, every action an agent takes costs the vendor computing power. The marginal cost is no longer close to zero, so heavy use under a flat fee is the vendor’s loss. In a survey (opens in a new tab) by the investment firm ICONIQ, software companies report an average gross margin of 45% on their AI products for 2025 and expect 53% for 2026, against the 83% Salesforce earns on its subscriptions.

An illustrative calculation shows what happens to a bill when agent charges replace licences. The hypothetical wholesaler in our post on standard software handles 75,000 orders a year in its enterprise resource planning (ERP) system, and that takes 40 people’s time. Its redesigned flow books eight in ten orders without a person and releases half of that time, worth €1.4 million a year.

Assume the vendor’s own agents achieve this, the best case for the vendor. Assume also that the time belongs to 40 employees with a licence at €100 a month each, and that 20 of them move to tasks outside the system. An action is a single step, such as checking stock, and costs €0.10 at Salesforce’s list price, which stands in here for an ERP vendor’s.

Actions per orderAgent charges per yearTotal with the 20 remaining licences
4€24,000€48,000
8€48,000€72,000
12€72,000€96,000

Illustrative: 60,000 orders handled by agents. Today the 40 licences cost €48,000 a year.

At four actions per order, the number in Microsoft’s own example (opens in a new tab) of an agent that processes orders, the charge by the task replaces exactly the licence revenue the vendor loses. Beyond that, the bill grows with every action an order takes. Charging by the task therefore protects the vendor’s revenue as licences disappear, and it ties the customer’s bill to a number the vendor designs and counts.

Why vendors charge both ways

Even so, vendors keep the licence and add the charge by the task on top, because revenue by usage is harder to forecast and agent products are still small. Salesforce reported (opens in a new tab) more than $1.5 billion of annual recurring revenue from them in August 2026, against about $46 billion of expected revenue for the year.

Where AI assists employees, the price per user rises. Salesforce’s 2026 editions (opens in a new tab) list at $195 and $395 per user per month for new purchases and replace editions at $175 and $350 (opens in a new tab). Where no user is involved, vendors charge by the action or by the resolved case, usually in credits, which are units bought in advance that each action consumes.

As a result, customers will pay both ways for some years, and vendors expect to earn more. Bain reviewed (opens in a new tab) the public prices of about 200 software vendors in June 2026 and found that, even among those moving beyond per-user pricing, most “are layering new meters on top of seats rather than replacing them outright”. Nadella told investors in October 2026 (opens in a new tab) that adding consumption to per-seat subscriptions is “expanding our TAM and ARPU”, meaning Microsoft’s market and its revenue per user.

Benioff aims higher and told investors he wants to be able to say: “give us $2 because we made you $20, or we made you $40”. For the wholesaler, a twentieth to a tenth of the €1.4 million gain would be €70,000 to €140,000 a year, up to three times today’s licence bill. It is an aim so far, and whether vendors reach it depends on who else can complete the task.

The price of a task depends on access to your data

Software features themselves give vendors little protection, because AI has made them cheaper to build and so easier to imitate. In McKinsey’s survey of August 2026 (opens in a new tab), 32% of respondents whose organisations use AI regularly said theirs had decided against buying a software product or feature it could build with AI coding tools.

The economist David Teece argued in 1986 (opens in a new tab) that when a product is easy to imitate, the profit may go to whoever owns the assets needed alongside it. For corporate software, we take those assets to be the system that holds the customer’s data and the integrations around it, the sources of lock-in. Network effects reinforce them: a system with more customers attracts more add-ons and trained specialists, which makes it more useful to each customer.

The third condition, lock-in, therefore decides what a task will cost. If an agent from another provider can complete the same task on that data, the vendor’s price per task has a competitor, and falling prices for AI models reach the customer. If it cannot, or only at a charge, the vendor’s agent has the advantage on its own system.

Vendors have begun to charge for that access. Salesforce announced on 17 September 2026 (opens in a new tab) that it will meter “every successful call a registered agent makes to Salesforce”. Its rate card (opens in a new tab) gives the rate as “TBA”, Salesforce promises 30 days’ notice before charging starts, and existing customers move to the new billing at renewal.

Microsoft publishes its charge for agents built outside its Copilot Studio tool: 0.1 credits per call to the ERP system, a fiftieth of the 5 credits an action costs.

Registering each agent is a security control a company needs anyway, and the amounts are small so far. In Salesforce’s words, however, registration “is what makes that agent’s activity visible, governable, and billable”. By setting the price of that access, the vendor also decides how much competition its own agents face, and with it what a task will cost.

What to settle before your next renewal

A buyer has the most influence over these prices before the vendor’s agents take over a workflow. Afterwards, the team that ran it has moved to other tasks, and the company depends on the agents. The next renewal is therefore the moment to settle the terms.

This matters first for contracts where agents will handle most cases, such as the service desk and order entry. Nadella said in April 2026 that nearly 60% of Microsoft’s customer-service customers already buy credits. We expect industry-specific suites to change later, because few alternatives exist.

Budget by the case. Work out what one case costs today in licences and in employees’ time, and compare every offer and every alternative on that figure. For the wholesaler it is roughly €37 of administration per order, and four actions at Salesforce’s list price would add €0.40.

Test a vendor’s agents on a sample of your own cases before adopting them, and ask for the units consumed per case and the AI model behind them. Without those figures, price lists cannot be compared, because the unit differs: an action at Salesforce and Microsoft, an AI Unit at SAP, a request or a document at Workday.

Each unit leaves a different risk with you. Per user, the vendor carries heavy use and you pay for idle licences. Per action, you carry the number of actions a case takes and, because credits expire, the forecast too. Per resolved case, the vendor carries failed attempts, and the definition of “resolved” decides the bill.

Fix the unit and its price for the term. The credits per action matter as much as the price per credit. Salesforce’s rate card says they “may be updated from time to time”, while Workday’s (opens in a new tab) are locked for the term of the order.

Ask what happens when the credits run out. Microsoft blocks agents at 125% of the prepaid amount unless pay-as-you-go billing is set up, Workday requires the customer to buy more or stop, and Salesforce and SAP bill the excess.

By our reading of today’s price lists, a vendor’s agent is often the cheapest way to automate a standard process. Owning a workflow pays where the process is specific to the business, as our comparison of buying and building sets out.

Whichever agent runs the workflow, ask for control over it: review thresholds for each type of case, a complete record of every decision, and notice before the model changes.

Above all, treat access to your data as the main term. Your own agents and tools should be able to reach and export your data, for use with the AI models you choose, at a price fixed for the term. Salesforce moves existing customers to its charge for outside agents at renewal and has not published the rate, so ask for it in writing before you renew.

A mid-sized customer will rarely change a large vendor’s standard terms, so reduce the lock-in yourself by keeping a current copy of your data outside the vendor’s system.

SalesforceMicrosoftSAP
Price per action$0.10$0.04 to $0.05 (opens in a new tab), more for reasoning modelsFrom about €0.14
Unused creditsExpire at the end of the termExpire each monthExpire after 12 months
Access for outside agentsCharge announced, rate not published0.1 credits per call (opens in a new tab) to the ERP system, waived for two premium licencesThrough a gateway; a separate control layer follows in early 2027 (opens in a new tab), price not published

List prices as published on 16 November 2026. SAP publishes no price list; its figure is calculated from the €700 per 100 AI Units in an SAP document for user groups (opens in a new tab).

Start with the contract that renews next

So pay-per-user will die slowly. The licence survives as an allowance of usage, and a growing share of the bill is charged by the task, at a price set by the competition the vendor’s agents face on your data. Keep access to your data open and fix the unit and its price at renewal, and falling AI prices can reach your bill; otherwise they stay with the vendor.

If a contract for one of your core systems renews in the next 12 months, send us its price list and a description of the workflow it supports. We will work out what a case costs under it, today and with the vendor’s agents, and make our assumptions explicit.

Write to us at info@formtwo.ai or enquire at formtwo.ai, and we will get back to you promptly.

All posts

Which process would you redesign first?

Tell us which workflow or system you want to reimagine and what it costs you today. We will get back to you within two business days, and if we can help, we will arrange a call to explore options together.

We reply within two business days.

Project details (optional)

When should the project begin?